Smartfuel innovation inside the AA Rewards coalition scheme

AA Rewards - New Zealand's number two coalition loyalty program behind Fly Buys - has struck a partnership deal with innovative loyalty start up Smartfuel. The deal means that AA Rewards points will disappear and the currency and rewards in the AA program will become accumulating fuel discounts.  AA Rewards members (and non-Members - see below) will now accumulate cents/litre discounts at AA Reward's participating retailers.  For instance a member might earn 3c/l at TelstraClear, 4c/l at Hammer Hardware and 10c/l at Take Note during the course of a week. This accumulates to a 17c/l discount when the member next fills up at BP or Caltex.

Non-members earn too

We first met Smartfuel early last year when they were building out a pilot of their program in Palmerston North.  The program launched on Monday of this week.  I spoke to Smartfuel's GM Ian Sutcliffe yesterday.  He said that not only was the current AA Rewards base going to benefit from this deal but those not paying an annual AA membership would also benefit (though at a lower rate).   This gives anyone the opportunity to participate.    

Ian Sutcliffe of Smartfuel 

Picture rights : MURRAY WILSON/Fairfax NZ

Richness, relevance

We know that members in the loyalty programs we operate improve their participation in the program in direct proportion to the increase in:

1. The richness of the rewards being offered  - the more you give back the more they'll spend with you, longer they'll stay a customer and more they'll recommend you
2. The relevance of those rewards  - the closer the rewards on offer are aligned with what they want, the harder they'll work to attain them.

Also - you have to have a match of both richness and relevance (one without the other will fail).  One criticism that's been leveled at Smartfuel is that the rewards are only fuel discounts and therefore will struggle on the relevance continuum.  That's possibly true but remember New Zealand has one of the highest rates of car ownership in the world so most people need to buy fuel regularly.  Looking at richness, Smartfuel seems to be offering more in some areas (not necessarily all) than comparable schemes.  For instance a WOF transaction at AA earns the member 30c/l discount.  With fuel at over $2.00, 30c/l off a $50 WOF is about a 30% discount.  Most retail programs offer less than 5% so this is pretty healthy.

Judging whether Smartfuel is rich enough or relevant enough may be missing the point though.  Their addition to AA Rewards program is a catalyst that makes the AA Rewards program far more valuable to their existing members and their existing retailers.

Education of the customer base

One of the big issues that Smartfuel is addressing is the education of customers into the accumulating portion of the program. Kiwis are used to collecting cents/litre offers from their supermarkets but not in rolling them together over 3 or 4 grocery visits into a single larger discount for their next petrol purchase.

We have re-branded as Aimia - Inspiring Loyalty

On Thursday the 6th October 2011 Carlson Marketing changed it's named globally to Aimia.

Carlson Marketing has been operating in New Zealand for over 30 years and we're trusted by some of the country's largest companies and brands to manage their customer, staff or channel loyalty programmes.  There are 1.5 million Kiwis in the the loyalty programmes we manage in New Zealand.

In 2009 we were acquired globally by Canadian based Groupe Aeroplan (GA) - a global loyalty programme powerhouse.  GA had already acquired the equivalents of New Zealand's Fly Buys coalition programme in Nectar (UK), Air Miles (Middle East) and Aeroplan (Canada).  They also owned one of the UK's leading loyalty and retail analytics companies in Loyalty Management Group.

We've spent the last 2 years integrating with our sister companies in the GA fold.  GA have expanded further around the globe with Nectar launching in Chile and Italy and investments in Club Premier (Aeroxexico's Frequent Flyer Programme) and Cardlytics (the USA's leading card transaction based marketing company).  They have also won the leading Australian supermarket Coles as a customer for loyalty analytics services.

Today we are Aimia.  Our new name cements the integration of our businesses into a global loyalty marketing leader.  Aimia is modern and distinctive and resonates in many languages.

• There is dialogue and movement within the name itself. The creation of Aimia was inspired by palindromes – words that read the same backwards and forwards, as they give the sense of two way conversation, a clear reflection of our approach to delivering value to our customers and consumers.
• It alludes to pinpoint precision – where two aims cross over. Whether it’s the sweet spot where the needs of clients and the wants of consumers overlap or the insight garnered from two different vantage points.
• It is inspired from the word ‘aim’: highlighting focus and precision, describing our expertise in targeting the right consumers with the right messages.  It is also from the French words ‘aimer’ or ‘ami’ emphasizing the importance of partnership and relationships and denoting a friendly tone and approach.
• The symmetry of Aimia mirrors the balance and partnership that sits at its core. A crosshair of aims, a meeting of minds. We see relationships differently.

We have over 3,700 Aimia colleagues in 20 countries around the world of which approximately:

• 1,885 are in Canada
• 850 are in the US
• 650 are in the Europe, Middle East and Africa region as well as in South America
• 475 are in the Asia-Pacific region

In New Zealand we are the same team with the some commitment to our client's success.  We will be transitioning over to Aimia during the remainder of this year.

February 10th - We present international mobile marketing case studies at Auckland's AmCham

We at Carlson Marketing count ourselves fortunate to have been trusted by our international clients to mobilise their businesses through apps, smartphones and mobile sites over the last few years. We'll be sharing some of our key learnings at the American Chamber of Commerce in Auckland on February the 10th.

Doug Rozen (our Senior VP Creative, Interactive, Media & Mobile based in the USA) will present a working model built up through his hands-on operational experience. He'l specifically discuss case studies from our clients:

• AT&T - a leading USA based Telco
• Coca-Cola - their new direct to customer strategies
• Amtrack - a leading US rail network
• The UK’s Nectar loyalty programme (Nectar is our sister company).

He’s a frequent speaker at mobile marketing events and most recently presented at ad:tech in New York.

Doug Rozen presenting at last year's loyalty conference in India

According to Doug "Around the world there is significant consideration and investment being placed in mobile marketing. The mobile channel offers not only a means to distribute marketing messages to customers on the go but also provides a litany of tactics. While many marketers are focused on the technological marvels that can be achieve through apps, there is a rising opportunity and more importantly a customer demand to add mobile as part of multi-channel CRM initiatives".

Doug Rozen interviewed at ad:tech in New York in November 2010

Date : Thursday the 10th February

Place : The University of Otago House, Street Level, 385 Queen Street Auckland

Time : Registration 3:45 pm

Presentation 4:00 pm

Refreshments 5:00 pm

Concludes 6:30 pm

If you would like to be our guest at this event please email me at simon.rowles@carlsonmarketing.co.nz or call on (09) 524 1122

Air New Zealand's Airpoints innovations (again)

Air New Zealand has recently delivered a comprehensive renewal of the Airpoints Dollars Frequent Flyer scheme. While it follows similar actions by Qantas Frequent Flyer in Australia it is a very Kiwi and innovative solution.

First mover - Qantas in Australia

Air New Zealand's new innovations follow moves in Australia by Qantas over the last 3 years. Qantas first signaled a partial listing of it's 5 million member Frequent Flyer Programme in 2008 which could have fetched it AU$1.5billion (for many airlines there's more money made in the frequent flyer scheme than in flying planes). The listing strategy was based in large part on Carlson Marketing's parent Groupe Aeroplan's success in Canada according to Simon Hickey - boss of Qantas Frequent Flyer in 2008. Qantas changed tack, held onto ownership of the Frequent Flyer programme, (which produces more profit than subsidiary Jetstar) and took it on an aggressive expansion drive.

Most frequent flyer programmes struggle with too many points being issued (typically by partners such as credit card companies and at a a compound annual growth rate of 10%) and not enough seats being available to redeem them (new planes add only 5% more seats to the global fleet per annum).

Qantas first addressed the redemption options from difficult-to-find-free-flights to include an online store stocked with merchandise and gift cards (full disclosure - we deliver this service for Qantas) and an any-seat, any-Qantas-flight redemption options. It then required all banks who were offering Qantas Frequent Flyer points on their credit cards along with other rewards to offer cards with Qantas Frequent Flyer points only (know as Direct Earn credit cards) - or not at all. Then last year it struck a deal with Woolworths Australia in which Woolies offered Qantas points to its shoppers and along the way added 700,000 new Qantas Frequent Flyer members.

The result? Depending on who you talk to either Qantas or FlyBuys is now the biggest and best loyalty programme in Australia. Either way - FlyBuys has a new attacker. And for Qantas it's a big earner : in the year to June 30, it generated underlying EBIT of A$328 million and now has a base of 7 million members.

Air New Zealand's strategy here

Air New Zealand didn't face the issues of limited seats being available for redemption in its Airpoints programme. In fact it could be argued that anything that got passengers onto it's planes was positive with the Centre For Aviation describing them as a "small airline getting smaller". The world first Airpoints Dollars innovation introduced a few years ago means any seat on any Air New Zealand flight could be bought with Airpoints (rather than the roughly 3%-5% of seats reserved per plane in other classic frequent flyer schemes).

Air New Zealand's advance in 6 steps

1. Flying on Air New Zealand flights had always gave customers Airpoints Dollars which could be redeemed for..
2. ...more Air New Zealand flights.
3. BNZ had long issued the GlobalPlus credit card on which customers earned even more Airpoints Dollars. ANZ (our client), Kiwibank and American Express have all issued new Airpoints Dollars credit cards over the last year.
4. Then recently - Air New Zealand enabled Fly Buys customers too to convert their Fly Buys points to Air New Zealand flights.
5. The really interesting piece has been the issuing of a new Airpoints membership card last month which is co-branded with Fly Buys by Air New Zealand. With this Airpoints card customers can now earn even more Airpoints Dollars (earned instead of Fly Buys points) at any of the Fly Buys merchants. This is a significant innovation and not one we've seen elsewhere. It's a collaborative local solution which is in contrast to the development of Qantas's programme in Australia.
6. The unexpected piece has been last week's release of an online Airpoints gift store. Airpoints Dollars can be used to buy goods and gifts from a $50 digital camera up to a $1,670 high end camera. Some goods are delivered in the same fashion as Fly Buys such as the new iPod Nano which must be picked up in store from Noel Leeming.

There are strong arguments in Australia to support the primacy of either Qantas Frequent Flyer or FlyBuys. In New Zealand - it looks like Air New Zealand's trumped them all.

Barclaycard Freedom - the (nearly) new credit card loyalty model

Barclaycard Freedom launched in the UK this month. It's an unusual model which has been implemented in similar forms in other parts of the world - most notable in our neighbourhood : Asia. BPI bank in the Philippines run this technology as their card loyalty program (called Real Thrills) as do Axis Bank in India (theirs is called Spice Rewards). The technology that underpins these offerings comes from France based Welcome Real-time who have been developing their solution for over 12 years (and with whom Carlson has a Asia Pacific partnership).

The mechanics (there are two) are similar in all applications :

(1) customers of the card company receive segmented offers at point of sale when they swipe their cards. These offers are printed on the till slip and are redeemable either back in that merchant or at another merchant.

(2) Customer of the card company can use their points to pay for their purchase at that merchant (not unlike ASB Bank's True Rewards program here in New Zealand).

The value of the first mechanic (offers on till slips) is clearer perhaps than the second (burning rewards points at the till). Most retailers want to get their customers through the till as fast as possible and any delay occasioned by a new process to redeem points wouldn't be appreciated. Importantly the retailer never knows the name or details of who they're making the offer to. They're simply card X which belongs to segment Y.

Merchants can set up segments of card carrying customer types from that issuer - a "frequent visitor" or a "never been here before" segment for example. These segments get different offers on the till slip. Frequent Visitor might get a "bring a friend for free next time offer" while Never Been Here Before might get a "come back and get a discounted item" offer. Merchants self manage these offers through an web portal.

What's different about Barclaycard's Freedom is that this is the first time this type of solution has been implemented on such a large scale in such a mature and sophisticated card market. The scale is significant. Barclaycard have 8 million customers who will be able to benefit from this solution at a large portfolio series of merchants (30,000 have been invited but less than that are available today). The goal is to have 200 outlets withing 5 miles of each customer making relevant offers.

If it pans out as its intended to then this is a great example of a marketing network in action. The three parties involved all benefit from relevance and richness.

The merchant is able to make different offers to different customers instead of the classic One Size Fits All structures. They don't have to incentivise business they were already going to get.

The customer gets an additional benefit on top of the others they're already receiving which, if the merchant gets their campaign management right, should be differently rich and differently relevant to each of them.

The bank in Barclaycard adds significant value to the near-commodity business of merchant acquiring as well as making their program an order of magnitude (again - if the merchants get their campaign management right) richer than competitor's card programs.

You are what you eat

There has been a long running loyalty program battle in the UK between Tesco (who were first to launch a loyalty card strategy in 1995) and Sainsburys who are a member of the Nectar coalition loyalty program (which I've written about before here). Much of the reporting about these retailers right now relates to their use and expenditure on their respective loyalty programs.

The battle heated up just before Christmas with Tesco doubling the points customers could earn - effectively doubling the value. Sainsbury's seems ave followed suit this month with an increase in the number of nectar points offered.

Tesco also mailed out GBP 67 million of vouchers in November that would normally have been sent in February.

So - who's winning?

Christmas trading results are due out in the next few days for Tesco but there's a concern that they've not got it right. Some analysts expect that their sales growth will be below that of their rivals. They're also concerned that Tesco will include GBP 100 million worth of loyalty vouchers in their sales figures (though the same analysts suggest that if they do this - decreasing their reported figures by 1.5% will deliver a true reflection of like-for-like sales).

Sainsbury's has already reported better than expected results for the Christmas period. In headlining these results - Sainsbury's CEO Justin King noted that "There will be a big difference between the haves and have-nots, with data. Those with loyalty data can see what customers are doing. If they are going elsewhere for a certain product, we can incentivise them to buy it with us.”

This is language that, in the past, would only have been heard from Tesco and their loyalty program partners dunhumby. In the Nectar program this data is worked by LMG Insight and Communication for Sainsbury (full disclosure : LMG is a sister company to Carlson Marketing. We're both owned by Groupe Aeroplan).

At Carlson we have always promoted the use of data to drive customer programs. The data in question for these two giants of UK grocery retailing is all the food their customers buy. The data that flows from customer's purchases of food is so accurate in determining their future buying habits that, in the words of the team at LMG, "You are what you eat".

Groupe Aeroplan Concludes Acquisition of Carlson Marketing

Montreal, QC – December 7, 2009 - Groupe Aeroplan Inc. (TSX: AER) today announced the

completion of the acquisition of Carlson Marketing, a privately-owned marketing services

provider headquartered in the United States.

“We are pleased to officially welcome Carlson Marketing to Groupe Aeroplan. As stated, the

combination of our companies positions Groupe Aeroplan as the global leader in loyalty

management,” said Rupert Duchesne, President and CEO. “This acquisition provides

immediate geographic diversification and accelerates Groupe Aeroplan’s international

expansion strategy into the G20 countries. Moreover, Carlson Marketing’s solid US presence

secures an important footprint in one of the largest consumer markets in the world.”

Groupe Aeroplan’s existing businesses and Carlson Marketing will continue to operate

separately and independently. Jeff Balagna, President and CEO of Carlson Marketing, and his

executive team, will continue the management of Carlson Marketing. Jeff has also been

named Executive Vice President, Groupe Aeroplan.

Carlson Marketing is widely recognized for its leading-edge global knowledge of loyalty

marketing services, and engagement and events management. It has strong client

relationships, which include some of the world’s most respected brands in important sectors

including financial services, automotive, high tech, consumer packaged goods and

pharmaceutical. Carlson Marketing has a presence in North America, Europe, Asia Pacific and

the Middle East.